Find a great therapist!

the easiest, and most affordable way to

If you've been thinking you might want some help, but haven't been sure where to find it (or how to afford it!)... this resource is for you!

help me find a counselor

And give me 10% off my first month!

Dating

Our Friends: Our Boyfriends’ Toughest Critics

I'm Stephanie May Wilson!

I'm an author and podcaster and my specialty is helping women navigate big decisions, life transitions — creating lives they love.

hey there

The beginning of the story

get a copy

Get my new book!

Girls Night Podcast

Navigating big decisions & life transitions — one girls night at a time!

TOp categories

The Gift Shop

Matching shirts and meaningful gifts for best friends.

Books & Courses

Books, courses, workbooks, and guides to help you create a life you love.

Create A Life You Love: Comes out on April 30th!

This is a topic I wanted to revisit. It's a post I wrote for my sweet friend Ally almost a year ago, but never shared with you guys! It's a particularly sweet topic for me now, watching my fiancé and my best friends, and my best friend's fiancé all come together in a big, puzzle-pieced kind of family. But it wasn't always this way, and that's the story I want to share with you today. If you're bringing someone home to meet your friends (often a scarier venture than meeting the parents), I hope this brings you some comfort. 

Carl and I flying to Denver for Thanksgiving


It’s that time in our lives when my friends and I are starting to pair up – less bad relationships and heartbreaks, more love and mentions of the future.


One of my best friends is a smitten mess right now. She calls me every few days and, without greeting, launches into, “I’m in love, I’m in love and I don’t care who knows it!”


But I do know it! I know it because I feel it too and I’m so glad to share my giddiness with her. I’m so excited to compare notes and squeal about dates and ask the hard questions that we’re afraid nobody else would understand.


Sharing your relationship with your friends is the best – but also terrifying.


My boyfriend and I live in Georgia – half a country away from my closest friends. They’ve heard all about him, asking all the right questions as I tell them the details of our dates and first kiss over Skype.


But I realized that there’s a bit of franticness about the way I tell those stories. It’s almost like I’m building a case for him – wanting to show them all the reasons he’s fantastic, almost pleading for them to love him.


And they should love him.


In the tender moments when I cry, or the funny moments when he laughs at me, or when we tell each other hard truths, I can picture my friends – ecstatic and teary as they remember the windy path that led to this relationship – as they see how well he treats me and how he loves me just the way that they do.


But still – every time I talk to them, I feel like a PR agent or someone performing a sales pitch. “And he’s nice and he’s funny and he treats me really well – but we fight and challenge each other, so it’s not puppy love or anything.”


Who am I trying to convince?


Over New Years, I brought him home. And with my heart beating wildly, he met some of the most important people in my life.


I felt like a pageant mom for both sides as I wanted to shine them all up, smooth down her hair, straighten his shirt – hissing at all of them to smile.


I watched with trepidation as they interacted – making a joke or two and asking questions about hometowns and siblings.


Several times I’ve even orchestrated an awkward Q&A, as I couldn’t figure out another way for them to get to know his heart in a short weekend. “Ask him questions!” I’d insist. “Babe – tell them how we met!”


Right… because that’s how deep friendships are formed.


My biggest fear was that they were going to see a snippet of my boyfriend and that somehow it would be the wrong one. Or the opposite – that he would see them in a weird moment, or someone would be trying too hard, and all bets would be off. One wouldn’t like the other and I’d get caught in the middle.


I needed my people to love each other. I wanted each of them to see the other for the amazing love story that they are – a story of great, miraculous love, and the string of best-friend-soul-mates that made it all possible.


But something beautiful has happened – as it usually does with some time and a dash of maturity.


We’ve built trust –


Now we’re the biggest supporters of each other’s relationships, instead of looking for holes. We’ve let go of some of our over-protectiveness – trusting our best friends to make good decisions – stepping in as a support when needed.


My girlfriends love my boyfriend – not because they’re best friends (not yet anyway…), not because they’ve known him forever, and not because he tap-danced and made dinner and bought them flowers all at the same time.


They love him because I love him. And as they look at me, shining and full of the real kind of love, they can see that this time is different.


Something’s different about this one and they don’t need to know him to see that.


And he loves them. He loves them because he knows they’ve had such a profound impact on me. He loves them because he sees the joy that they bring me, and wants me to be filled with that love and joy always. He loves them because I love them.


And the best part is that we have time. With two camps of people that love me – one on either side – I get to sit in the middle knowing that over time and organically, the two will come together. And that in the meantime, they’ll love each other because they both love me.


The performance is over. The critics are satisfied. I’m safe, right in the middle.


Are you and your friends protective of each other? Have you ever been nervous to introduce them to someone you're dating?

+ show Comments

- Hide Comments

add a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. Catherine says:

    I was saying to a married friend last night, “I’m almost always surprised by who my friends pick.” And not necessarily in a bad way, either, just, surprised. We talked about love and choice and “what if there’s a better one down the road” and how ultimately you can’t live like that. I have definitely been skeptical of friends’ boyfriends, but I become less so when they’re husbands. I think it has a lot to do with commitment: show me you’re committed, and I’ll accept you (well, most of you… 🙂

Sign up for my newsletter and get weekly emails with stories, resources, updates (and discounts!) you won't find anywhere else. 

Get on the list,
and never miss a thing!

    Let's be friends!